Question: Did Julia Really Betray Winston?

What happened between Winston and Julia?

Julia is Winston’s lover and the only other person who Winston can be sure hates the Party and wishes to rebel against it as he does.

Winston essentially sees their affair as temporary; his fatalistic attitude makes him unable to imagine his relationship with Julia lasting very long..

What does Winston fear most?

Winston fears rats. … He then revealed that he feared rats more than anything else in the world. This same fear is what O’Brien eventually used to get Winston to betray his love for Julia.

Why did Winston Smith loved Big Brother?

Through this act, Winston’s self-preservation overcomes his desire for self-expression. He has conquered his individuality and submitted once again to Party group-think. He loves Big Brother, because he no longer has an individual will; his will has become part of societal group-mind.

Did Mr Charrington betray Winston?

They were betrayed by Mr. Charrington who was actually an undercover member of the Thought Police and O’Brien who was a devoted Inner Party member. Ironically, following their arrest, Winston was tortured by O’Brien himself in a bid to cure him.

What is the biggest danger to Big Brother 1984?

Thanks to answers.com, “The greatest threat to the inner party is people of the party and/or the proles beginning to think as individuals with their own individual feelings allowing them to revoke the subhumaness that the party has placed upon them and possibly use that power to revolt”.

Did Julia really love Winston?

Julia is attracted to Winston and even tells him that she loves him despite never having spoken to him before because she saw “something in [his] face” that told her “[he was] against them.” Although Winston is ten to fifteen years older than Julia and is not described as being particularly physically attractive, Julia …

Why did Winston want to kill Julia?

And this view is never challenged by the only woman who doesn’t fit quite into this narrative: Julia might be different, she is still first and foremost defined as a female body. It it thus undeniable that Winston started out hating Julia simply because he wanted to have sex with her.

What was Julia’s worst fear in 1984?

Julia was a sexual animal. She loved sleeping with men. They could have threatened her with altering her beauty, but it is ambiguously described and from the fact that she sleeps with older, less-than handsome men like Winston, I don’t think that was it. Castration would have been terrifying to her.

Why does Winston Love Obrien?

He begins to love O’Brien, because O’Brien stops the pain; he even convinces himself that O’Brien isn’t the source of the pain. O’Brien tells Winston that Winston’s current outlook is insane, but that torture will cure him. … O’Brien offers to answer his questions, and Winston asks about Julia.

Why was Syme vaporized?

The reason why Syme was vaporized as what Winston thought was he was way too intelligent. He was able to understand why he was creating the new edition of the Newspeak dictionary as shown when he talks to Winston. He knew way too much. Somewhere that intelligent might overthrow the government of Oceania.

What does Julia symbolize in 1984?

Julia is Winston Smith’s love-interest and his ally in the struggle against Big Brother. She represents the elements of humanity that Winston does not: pure sexuality, cunning, and survival. … She busies herself with getting around the Party, unlike Winston, who wishes to attack the Party at its center.

Why does Winston believe he has not betrayed Julia?

Winston says he has not betrayed Julia. … He admits to himself that he still loves Julia and that in the moment that he cries for her, he realized that he loved more then, than he ever has. He also thought about how he obeyed the Party but he still hated the Party.

Why can’t Winston and Julia get married?

Winston and Julia can not get married because they are committing adultery and would go to prison or executed.

What are Julia’s weaknesses in 1984?

Short answer: she is smart in a sly way, she is analytical and realistic, and she is very strong-willed in a dystopian society. Weaknesses: Julia is a slave to herself. What i mean to say is that her own personal wishes dictate her actions.

Did Winston betray Julia?

In “1984”, in room 101, Winston was forced to betray Julia by asking them to “give” the rats to her. … By the end of it all, Winston meets Julia long enough to tell her that he doesn’t love her anymore, but he’s sure that he loves Big Brother.